Mac Studio or 16in M1 MacBook Pro initial for graphic structure, movie editing?

I will buy a Mac for graphic style and motion picture editing. I want to have a laptop computer and desktop.

With Intel Macs, there employed to be a significant overall performance variance concerning the mobile processors in laptops and the desktop processors & GPUs, but with Apple Silicon it can be all the very same, and the change among a M1 Max in a laptop and M1 Max in a Studio is maybe a bit far better & quieter efficiency less than load since of the better cooling.

Apart from that, the Mac Studio has more ports than the MBP (you’ll require to use at least one to attach a display screen, but you are even now forward of the sport – but the MBP still has rather excellent I/O & you can get a lot more if you add a TB4 hub).

With Apple Silicon, I imagine it genuinely arrives down to irrespective of whether you desire desktop or notebook:

– if you might be under no circumstances likely to use your Mac for movie/graphics operate “on the street”, get a desktop (& perhaps an iPad or Air for cell basics)
– if not, get a MacBook Pro, a massive exhibit and external keyboard & mouse.

In your case, I’d advise beginning with a M1 Professional MBP + screen/keyboard/mouse and use that to investigate whether you really want a (a) a independent desktop and (b) regardless of whether you could acquire advantages of a M1 Max (which is generally just excess GPU cores and an additional media processor). If you do go on to get a Studio, you’d currently have the display and keyboard…

If you seriously want to have two individual devices, which is high-quality – but with Apple Silicon it really is not definitely a requirement introduced on by overall performance dissimilarities. If you’re unquestionably definitely acquiring the two extended-expression then be mindful that the Studio is only about 6 months aged and not likely to be updated for a though, whereas the 16″ MacBook Pro is coming up to it truly is 1st birthday and could be acquiring an update to M2 in advance of the finish of the year. Nonetheless, nobody is familiar with for confident that this will come about & we’re nonetheless in the dark about how often we can expect Apple Silicon machines to get updates. There is certainly generally a rumour of new products coming out genuine soon now…

Apple seemingly has resolved to not deal with the commonly claimed whining audio thats inflicting some of the Mac Studios.

It is really challenging to say whether or not this is a serious difficulty just by wanting at posts. Whatsoever machine you obtain, a proportion are shipped defective. There are also two independent challenges – some folks are unquestionably hearing a distracting whine (which is a fault) – other individuals are let down that the Studio fan operates constantly and is not 100% silent (but it is extremely peaceful and seldom, if at any time, revs up – whilst other Macs are useless silent when idle but get rather noisy less than load) & are maybe having obsessive as a outcome.

My tactic would be: the Mac Studio shouldn’t whine audibly. If you get one and it whines, get a substitution. If the alternative whines, return it and get your cash back.